While I was in Arizona visiting family, twice I found myself at the start of comments that I couldn’t finish. Actually, I eventually was able to fight through and finish one of the comments but the other was more of a story and there was no chance of finishing it. I felt there were several large waves of emotions waiting to crash down on me if I proceeded. After a couple of false starts, I wisely aborted. I considered that it would be easier to write than to verbalize, in more ways than one!
(Side note: When the first wave overtook me, one of my sisters said, “It’s OK, we understand. We read your blog.” Yes! It was so great that I didn’t need to try to explain it all again. My brother’s wife then commented that the loosely-tethered emotions are akin to having PMS. Good point, besides, it is just one more letter than MS.)
Anyway, we were talking about raising teenagers and one of my younger sisters said, “David, I vaguely remember you and Dad arguing, something about music.” I’m not sure if she wanted me to confirm and flesh out the memory or if she wanted to know how I felt about that debate now that I am the father of an oft-belligerent 15-year-old son.
I didn’t wait for a question; I jumped right in with the story; at least as far as I could before sounding like a tortured seal with a cold! But here is the story.
It was 1981. I was 16 and had purchased one of my very few albums. (I think I bought three during my entire teen years.) Unfortunately, the last track contained a vulgarity. I was embarrassed by it, and each time the music reached a certain point, I quickly got up and found the volume knob so I could mute the offensive word.
When Dad learned of this he was concerned. Seated alone at the dining room table, he voiced his concern over the inappropriate lyric. His comment was neither inflammatory nor untrue. However, for some reason I dug in and tried to stubbornly defend my position. Any position. (I think it had more to do with the sibling that had “ratted” on me and was not out of earshot of this discussion than on my affection for this somewhat drippy rock band.) My arguments included that I didn’t know about the lyric when I made the purchase, I hear that word and worse at school each day, AND I always turn it down anyway. I used the “logical extremes” tactic that if he thought I should get rid of the record, then perhaps I should also quit school. I also used the irrelevant “big picture halo” approach, by pointing out that there are worse sins I could commit and at least I turned it down each time. And I even combined the two with “I try so hard to be good and then you focus on this one little thing and think I’m an evil sinner.” (Oooh, I loathe that approach and believe me, I’ve been heartily repaid in-kind for using it.)
The debate grew longer and louder. He couldn’t concede his point that I probably shouldn’t have such music in our home and I wasn’t about to concede my points that (1) it was far better than schoolyard talk and (2) through my efforts it was harmless. Notice that our positions were not necessarily opposites. He wasn’t arguing that schoolyard jargon is better than the lyric, nor was he saying that it was harmful despite my censoring. But those were the only points I could defend.
Anyway, these kinds of debates typically end when someone storms off in exasperation. It is a tactic often employed by the party that has the weaker case, as if the “storm off and door slam” somehow add merit to the argument. And so it was that night. I angrily reiterated my points and marched upstairs to my room. I didn’t often slam the door but I did this night. I wanted to really emphasize my points by banging lumber! Oooh I was mad. I lied in my bed, seething. I mulled over my points, entrenched myself deeper in my flawed logic and continued to convince myself that I was right! Ten minutes later I was still fuming when it happened.
There was a soft knock on my door. It was Dad. His countenance had changed. He wasn’t there to argue. He apologized that he had gotten angry, and asked my forgiveness. He added some words affirming his high esteem of and love for me. That was it. There were no conditions nor counsel, no preaching nor pride. He turned and quietly left the room.
A thousand sermons on humility (or on effective parenting) were never more powerful. I was no longer seething. I wasn’t even angry, except at myself for being so stubborn and difficult. Literally within a minute I fetched the record, snapped it in two, and threw it away. I don’t know that I ever reported this act to Dad, but it didn’t really matter. What mattered is on that night, a boy learned that his father valued their relationship more than his own pride, even when Dad was “in the right.”
I’ve found that experiencing this as a teen and replicating it as a father is not as natural as I had envisioned, especially given that this was not an isolated occurrence. My son takes identical approaches and defends “logical” strongholds. It can be so exasperating and our relationship has waned. I forget that being “right” doesn’t always justify my sternness. I have no excuse for not knowing better. I will try.